NASWCANEWS.ORG
  • Commentary
    • Feature
    • Messages
    • Opinion
    • Letter To The Editor
  • News
    • Announcements
    • Events
    • Around the State
    • News
  • Action
    19th Annual Hall of Distinction. Sunday October 17, 2021 from 1-2:30pm.

    19th Annual Social Work Hall of Distinction

    In Memoriam

    In Memoriam: Rino Patti, 85, dean and professor emeritus

    NASW-CA Members Get A $35 Discount When Enrolling In Exam Prep Course from Therapist Development Center – Limited Supply!

    Submit Your Nominations: 2021 NASW-California Chapter’s Annual Social Worker Awards

    SF & Marin Units Hosting Social Work Month Celebration On March 30th

    Reminder: NASW-CA Offering Scholarships For Online CEUs For Social Workers Affected By Natural Disasters

    SAVE THE DATE: 2021 Statewide Membership Meeting On February 4th!

    NASW-CA President Dr. Sylvester Bowie’s Statement: The Importance Of Naming Kamala Harris As The VP Candidate — Now let’s get to work!

    NASW-CA President Dr. Sylvester Bowie’s Statement: The Importance Of Naming Kamala Harris As The VP Candidate — Now let’s get to work!

    Executive Director’s Message: Congratulations Social Work Graduates

    Executive Director’s Message: The Power And Meaning Behind Juneteenth

  • Education
    • Professional Development
  • Reports
    • Region A
    • Region B
    • Region C
    • Region D
    • Region E
    • Region F
    • Region G
    • Region H
    • Region I
    • Los Angeles Region Map
    • California Region Map
  • Ads
    • Classifieds
    • Display Ads
    • How to Advertise
  • Membership
  • Videos
No Result
View All Result
  • Commentary
    • Feature
    • Messages
    • Opinion
    • Letter To The Editor
  • News
    • Announcements
    • Events
    • Around the State
    • News
  • Action
    19th Annual Hall of Distinction. Sunday October 17, 2021 from 1-2:30pm.

    19th Annual Social Work Hall of Distinction

    In Memoriam

    In Memoriam: Rino Patti, 85, dean and professor emeritus

    NASW-CA Members Get A $35 Discount When Enrolling In Exam Prep Course from Therapist Development Center – Limited Supply!

    Submit Your Nominations: 2021 NASW-California Chapter’s Annual Social Worker Awards

    SF & Marin Units Hosting Social Work Month Celebration On March 30th

    Reminder: NASW-CA Offering Scholarships For Online CEUs For Social Workers Affected By Natural Disasters

    SAVE THE DATE: 2021 Statewide Membership Meeting On February 4th!

    NASW-CA President Dr. Sylvester Bowie’s Statement: The Importance Of Naming Kamala Harris As The VP Candidate — Now let’s get to work!

    NASW-CA President Dr. Sylvester Bowie’s Statement: The Importance Of Naming Kamala Harris As The VP Candidate — Now let’s get to work!

    Executive Director’s Message: Congratulations Social Work Graduates

    Executive Director’s Message: The Power And Meaning Behind Juneteenth

  • Education
    • Professional Development
  • Reports
    • Region A
    • Region B
    • Region C
    • Region D
    • Region E
    • Region F
    • Region G
    • Region H
    • Region I
    • Los Angeles Region Map
    • California Region Map
  • Ads
    • Classifieds
    • Display Ads
    • How to Advertise
  • Membership
  • Videos
No Result
View All Result
NASWCANEWS.ORG
No Result
View All Result
Home Opinion

OPINION: The passing of Proposition 22 and a possible role for social workers

by Staff
March 2, 2021
in Opinion
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

by Brian Kaufman, LCSW
Chair, NASW-CA Social Work Occupational Council

One of the reasons I started the Social Work Occupational Council is to shed light on issues such that was raised last year when Proposition 22 was on the ballot. The NASW California Chapter opted to take no position on whether to endorse or oppose the measure. Although I have been critical of this decision, I do not blame them for taking that position. I certainly do respect this decision, as it was based on the will of the Legislative Committee which is representative of the membership as a whole. I am far more critical of the Proposition 22 backers themselves who put out a massive amount of misinformation and the Proposition 22 opponents who failed to counter that message effectively.

The backers’ claims that app delivery drivers want to remain independent or that being independent somehow offers them more flexibility is inaccurate and misleading. Existing law would have already reclassified these drivers as employees (Said, 2020). Their ability to choose their own schedule would not have been taken away, but instead they would have received all the protections that ordinary employees take for granted. 

Rideshare and app delivery drivers are the very people for whom social workers should advocate. According to the UCLA Labor Center (2018), two out of every three rideshare drivers in Los Angeles report that they rely on driving as their main source of income. Now that Proposition 22 has passed rideshare drivers remain independent but at a huge financial cost.  Being independent means no sick leave or paid family leave and no workman’s compensation if there is an accident. They are completely on their own if something were to happen to them and in a pandemic missing work due to illness means not being able to provide for their family. Passing Proposition 22 told companies like Uber and Lyft that if they want to get around labor laws all they had to do was to pour millions into a ballot measure to carve out exceptions for their workers. But more importantly this proposition has the effect of keeping worker pay low, and thus denying an entire class of workers a living wage and further exacerbating income inequality. We are now starting to see this, as Albertson’s recently announced they would lay off their own delivery drivers in favor of utilizing app-based drivers (Rosenberg, 2021).

As we move ahead to a new year, new concerns continue to arise about what it means to be an employee versus being an independent contractor. There has been a lot of talk about other workers requesting similar exemptions from California labor law in order to remain independent contractors including social workers. I argue that we must resist this trend and call out companies that abuse their workers in this way. We must continue to advocate for legislation that protects workers and not corporate bottom lines. The alternative will only lead to lower salaries for everyone.

If we are ever to achieve higher salaries and better benefits for workers, staying independent is not the answer. Instead, we must look at creative alternatives such as worker cooperatives or owning your own hiring agency or better yet have all the app-based drivers create their own app and have the profits shared equally among everyone. 

Organizing workers in this way may not be a traditional role for social workers, but I believe that social workers have a unique set of skills that are ideal for this task. It is just another form of community organizing but in a way that helps these families achieve a living wage and be more self-sufficient.

You can reach Brian at bkaufman.nasw@gmail.com and naswcaswoc@gmail.com.

References

Rosenberg, E.  (2021, Jan 6).  Albertsons is laying off employees and replacing them with gig workers, as app platforms rise. Retrieved from https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/2021/01/06/vons-albertsons-doordash-prop-22-layoffs/

Said, C.  (2020, Jun 10).  California regulators say Uber, Lyft drivers are employees. Retrieved from https://www.sfchronicle.com/business/article/California-regulators-say-Uber-Lyft-drivers-are-15330779.php

UCLA Labor Center (2018).  More than a gig: A survey of ride hailing drivers in Los Angeles.  Retrieved from https://www.labor.ucla.edu/publication/more-than-a-gig/

Staff
Website | + posts
  • Staff
    https://naswcanews.org/author/staff/
    LGBTQ+ Social Worker Social & Support on September 14
  • Staff
    https://naswcanews.org/author/staff/
    NASW-CA’s Statement on ASWB’s Clinical Exam Pass Rates Report
  • Staff
    https://naswcanews.org/author/staff/
    API Social Work Council Northern California's August Networking Forum - Macro Social Work on August 24
  • Staff
    https://naswcanews.org/author/staff/
    Third Legislative Update Since Lobby Days

Related Posts

Of Keys and Locks: CalAIM Will Eventually Unlock Doors That Permit SNF Diversion/Transition to RCFEs for Thousands of Participants
Opinion

Of Keys and Locks: CalAIM Will Eventually Unlock Doors That Permit SNF Diversion/Transition to RCFEs for Thousands of Participants

August 9, 2022
Steps Forward: The Medi-Cal Asset Limit Will Change in July 2022
Opinion

Steps Forward: The Medi-Cal Asset Limit Will Change in July 2022

June 16, 2022
Dear Social Work Graduates: Take Risks.
Messages

Dear Social Work Graduates: Take Risks.

May 24, 2022
From Micro to Macro: Interning with NASW-CA
Opinion

From Micro to Macro: Interning with NASW-CA

May 23, 2022
Innovating Medicare: The Choose Home Care Act could allow 700,000 seniors each year to receive rehabilitation at home instead of at skilled nursing homes
Opinion

Innovating Medicare: The Choose Home Care Act could allow 700,000 seniors each year to receive rehabilitation at home instead of at skilled nursing homes

May 16, 2022
Putting Action Behind Your Words: Reflections on 2022 Lobby Days
Opinion

What is Title Protection and why does California need Title Protection for all social workers? 

May 10, 2022
Facebook Twitter Instagram Youtube

National Sites:

NASW National Site
NASW Press
Social Workers Speak
NASW Blogs
Privacy Policy

Contact Us

NASW-CA Chapter
1016 23rd Street
Sacramento, CA 95816
Phone: 916-442-4565
Fax: 916-442-2075
email: naswnews@naswca.org

California Sites:

NASW California Chapter
Socialwork Web
Become a Member

© 2020 naswcanews - All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Commentary
    • Feature
    • Messages
    • Opinion
    • Letter To The Editor
  • News
    • Announcements
    • Events
    • Around the State
    • News
  • Action
  • Education
    • Professional Development
  • Reports
    • Region A
    • Region B
    • Region C
    • Region D
    • Region E
    • Region F
    • Region G
    • Region H
    • Region I
    • Los Angeles Region Map
    • California Region Map
  • Ads
    • Classifieds
    • Display Ads
    • How to Advertise
  • Membership
  • Videos

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist